Modern War magazine #34 - Opaque War: Ukraine 2014 (2 Player)

Nathangun

FGM Brigadier
FGM MEMBER
Opaque War: Ukraine 2014 is a simulation of the military confl ict between the Ukraine government and the Donbass rebels (the People’s Republic of Donetsk and the People’s Republic of Luhansk).

pic3809685.jpg

Game play begins in April 2014 when the Ukrainian government launched the so-called Anti-Terrorist Operation (ATO), to assert its control over the rebel provinces.
There are two players in the game: The Ukrainian Government player (Ukraine) and the Donbass Rebel player (Rebel). The Ukrainian player assumes the role of the commander of the Ukrainian Regular Army and the nationalist militias, police, and border guard forces. The Rebel player assumes the role of the commanders of the breakaway republics of Luhansk and Donetsk and (eventually) Russian support units.
The Ukrainian player must attempt to put down the insurrection by securing Luhansk, Donetsk, and the Donetsk Airport, as well as prevent their capture by Rebel forces. In addition, the Ukrainian player should seek to control all the Russian border crossings into the Donetsk and Luhansk oblasts, if he can.
The Rebel player must attempt to deny control of Luhansk, Donetsk, and the Donetsk Airport to the Ukrainian player, while also seeking to place Novoazovsk, Mariupol, and hex 1006 (the rail links to the Crimea) firmly in Rebel hands.

pic6324435.png


A review from the BGG website:

I've just had my first game with... my UKRAINIAN opponent (just to be clear, actual real life nationality Ukrainian). This makes the subject matter much more real.

For starters, he can pronounce every city and town on the map.Thats a bonus. And oddities occur , such as when he said, "why Oblast? That seems like a strange word." I replied, "what do you mean, isn't that the correct word?". He said that because he was thinking in English, "Oblast" caused some cognitive dissonance (surprisingly, Russian language for "cognitive dissonance is... "cognitive dissonance" 99% the same words). He wanted the equivalent in English... I suggested "Province", and he was much happier with that when he was in "English language mode".

Now here's the thing. When playing a WWII game, say replaying, Operation Barbarossa, you're replaying something that happened generations ago - its history. You'd think WWII happened recently judging by the comments in a typical youtube video; Russians will say, "we won it."; Americans will jump in with, "Commie scum, WE won it with D-Day & Lend-Lease; Brits will go on about Enigma beating Hitler; all Aussies know that the Rats of Tobruk took out the Third Reich, Poles will troll, reminding everyone about massacres... you know what I mean - unless you've only watched video's with disabled comments.

But WWII is history. Sure it shaped the 20th Century. But its history. And anyone still living who was in it, really in it, frontline, isn't talking about it - and they never did. Its a distant memory. It's safe (Mind you, if I'm reading a set of rules with a Swastika on the cover - I will hide it - not entirely work-safe from the ignorant).

Ukraine 2014 is in the here and now. OK, its 2019. But to Ukrainians, its still happening because... it really is still happening.

I can only guess how disturbing playing this game is for my Ukrainian opponent. Actually, I'm not guessing. He said, "this is disturbing." He has visited, worked, has relatives, friends, spent time, in every city and town on the map. His personal friendships have been torn asuna (sorry, "asunder" - too much SAO) by the Ukraine vs Russia dynamic that happened in 2014 and continues to this day.

It is an emotional rollercoaster. My Ukrainian friend does not see the rebels in Donetsk as evil. Nor does he see the Ukrainians as evil NAZI's, even though he is aware that Ukraine is ridiculously portrayed as NAZI in Russian propaganda; while he is quite aware that a tiny percentage of Ukrainian ARE actual NAZI's... the gamut of emotions is many and varied. So convoluted and disturbing.

Every turn of the game created a gateway into a real life anecdote about someone he knows in this town or that town. Its like those war movies where one brother fights for the north, and the other for the south.

Even the confusion we had in the first game replicated the confusion of what was happening on the ground in Ukraine in 2014.

This isn't a review. But I will say, as a game, it is looking good so far. I will be honest and say that I thought the subject matter was interesting, but probably the gameplay wouldn't cut it. But to my surprise, it DOES seem to work as a game. And I think this is the only game where you might shoot Flight MH-17. If MH-17 (remember that?) does get shot down, it is very significant for Ukraine; makes sense, because lets face it, that's one of the reasons why anyone in the west is even vaguely aware that something is happening over there.

I do have a Russian gaming friend. I did entertain the thought of pairing him up with Ukrainian friend and watch them play Ukraine 2014. But after seeing the trauma, that is a non starter. Friendships would be lost. Possibly blood spilled. Saying, "Its just a game" wouldn't diffuse it.

Opaque War. Aptly named. And the most traumatic experience I have had since playing, "THIS WAR OF MINE".


 
Top Bottom