Welcome to The Few Good Men

Thanks for visiting our club and having a look around, there is a lot to see. Why not consider becoming a member?

What's the Hold-Up, Monty? | British and Canadian Forces in Normandy

Magpie

FGM Sergeant
FGM MEMBER
Joined
May 9, 2021
Messages
111
Reaction score
65
Age
37
Location
Alberta
tiger.jpg

Today, I'm recommending a Youtube video:

D-Day for the Allies: Gold, Juno and Sword Beach Landings

What's it about? Rickard examines the Anglo-Canadian side of the Normandy invasion, addressing questions like: WHY didn't Monty capture Caen on schedule? WHY didn't the Anglo-Canadians break out before the Americans did? WHY did the repeated Anglo-Canadian offensives have such mixed results? WHY did Monty do what he did?

The video is presented by John Nelson Rickard, a former Canadian armoured officer and historian. If you find the first few minutes of his talk unimpressive, I encourage you to persevere - he's a better speaker than he might seem at first, he knows the material, and he makes some excellent points.

I'm recommending this video because it explained the battle of Normandy more concisely than any history book I've ever read.

Rickard does not focus on the Canadians or British armies only. One of the most important points of his presentation is that the Allied armies in Normandy were A TEAM:

"A lot of World War Two history gets written from nationalist perspectives, but it really was a team effort."




Some highlights:

8:10 - first use of the word "Sorry"

19:17 - the British "should've" broken out to the east and south + the Four Cardinal Directions

22:25 - Rommel's plan to repulse the Allies

30:03 - a reference to Saving Private Ryan

30:38 - Monty's real plan for capturing the Caen airfields

40:34 - Monty's master plan (in Normandy)

45:25 - Operation Goodwood

1:09:33 - the Essential Thing (D +82)
 
Last edited:
Back
Top